Taken from a demonstration I gave at NWP summer institute:
“In the art of living, man is both the artist and the object of his
art;
he is the sculptor and
the marble; the physician and the
patient.”
-Erich Fromm
Students are being terribly
mis-trained about the nature of knowledge, about the way that we learn, and
about the connections that exist between all things that can be known, and they are being mislead by
their own educational system. I have had students remark that I was drifting
from my subject matter during my occasional forays into science, social studies
and mathematics, and I expected those comments to some degree. I realized there
was a problem when a student appealed to me in my English class: “Why are we
reading so much? This is English class!”
The
general education that students receive in public school creates a false
impression of the world being divided-up by subject when there are no such
walls in the real world. Students are taught to think linearly, inside several different boxes, and to
never let thoughts from one box interfere with those of other
compartments. A superior education is
both broad and deep. It enables students to view the world in an objective, quantifiable
way as well as with a subjective and philosophical eye. The late Dr. Philip
Phenix, Professor Emeritus of Philosophy and Education at the Teachers College
of Columbia University once summed up a person of superior education as (1964):
“[being] skilled in the use of speech, symbol, and
gesture, factually well informed, capable
of creating and appreciating objects of esthetic significance, endowed with a rich and disciplined life in relation to
self and others, able to make wise decisions and
to judge between right and wrong, and possessed of an integral outlook. These are the aims of general education for
the development of whole persons.” (Phenix, 1964)
So what does this have to do with writing? In Write for Insight: Empowering Content Area
Learning, Grades 6-12, is says “If students are to make knowledge their
own…they must struggle with the details, wrestle with the facts, and rework raw
information and dimly understood concepts into language they can communicate to
someone else.” (Strong, 2006)
If we want students to really learn information, and not regurgitate
it, they must interact with it,
through writing, and through communities of learning where they can teach what
they have discovered to others.
No comments:
Post a Comment